Connect Pro

MLB The Show Captains

MLB The ShowCaptains

In MLB The Show's Diamond Dynasty mode, Captains help players create themed teams by offering stat boosts for meeting certain criteria. adding more eligible players unlocks up to three higher boost tiers, each offering larger stat increases.

Tier 1Tier 2Tier 3
Player Card Image

Players from the Colorado Rockies 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Todd Helton

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players who played in the Negro Leagues

Cards Required: 2

Buck Leonard

Power Right

3

Power Left

3

Batting Clutch

3

Hits Per Bf

3

Player Card Image

Players from the Sacramento Athletics

Cards Required: 5

Matt Holliday

Contact Right

8

Contact Left

8

Batting Clutch

8

Hits Per Bf

8

Player Card Image

Players from the Miami Marlins 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Preston Wilson

Contact Right

8

Contact Left

8

Batting Clutch

8

Hits Per Bf

8

Player Card Image

Players from the New York Yankees 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Babe Ruth

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Philadelphia Phillies 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Kyle Schwarber

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Los Angeles Dodgers 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Max Muncy

Contact Right

3

Contact Left

3

Batting Clutch

3

Hits Per Bf

3

Player Card Image

Players from the Kansas City Royals 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

George Brett

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Seattle Mariners 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Richie Sexson

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Pitching Clutch

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Texas Rangers 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Ian Kinsler

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the St. Louis Cardinals 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Jim Edmonds

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Washington Nationals 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

James Wood

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the San Francisco Giants 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Hank Thompson

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Chicago White Sox 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Frank Thomas

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Cincinnati Reds 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Johnny Bench

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Tampa Bay Rays 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Junior Caminero

Contact Right

8

Contact Left

8

Batting Clutch

8

Hits Per Bf

8

Player Card Image

Players from the Chicago Cubs 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Alfonso Soriano

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Baltimore Orioles 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Cal Ripken Jr.

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

8

Player Card Image

Players from the Pittsburgh Pirates 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Andrew McCutchen

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Houston Astros 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Craig Biggio

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

Player Card Image

Players from the Los Angeles Angels 91 OVR or lower

Cards Required: 5

Bobby Grich

Contact Right

5

Contact Left

5

Batting Clutch

5

Hits Per Bf

5

ShowZone Newsletter

Stay up-to-date on everything MLB The Show.

Perfect-Perfect Grid Game

Play ShowZone's Perfect Perfect Grid. It's free & new ones daily!
Showzone Logo
ShowZone logo
ShowZone is a Video Game Numbers project. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.
ShowZone LLC ©2025

TOP CONTENT

What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?What are the best Kontrol Freeks for MLB The Show?What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

Mobile AppBrowser ExtensionShowZone Discord

Our Other Projects

College PigskinBest Local Card ShopsSportCalcsVideo Game Numbers

Site Information

ShowZone ProContactReport an IssueAdvertising & PartnershipsPrivacy Policy